Duarte Nursery Sued to Get Back About $800,000 in State-Mandated Fees for Grapevine Research. A Court Called Its Appeal “Long on Innuendo and Short on Evidence.”
After a pest ravaged more than 50,000 acres of Napa and Sonoma vineyards, the Legislature made grape rootstock nurseries fund research on healthier rootstock. Duarte Nursery challenged the fee in federal and state court and lost both times.

In the late 1980s, phylloxera, a tiny insect that feeds on grapevine roots, ravaged vineyards in Napa and Sonoma counties. About 70% of the vineyards there were planted on a rootstock called AXR#1, which a 1991 University of California report found vulnerable to a new strain of the pest. The damage reached more than 50,000 acres in the Napa-Sonoma region, and growers had to replant at $30,000 to $50,000 an acre, according to a 2015 state appeals court opinion. The court put the cost to the industry at up to an estimated $1 billion.
In 1992, the Legislature passed a law creating the California Grape Rootstock Improvement Commission to fund research on healthier rootstock. After an industry referendum in 1993, the commission held its first meeting in January 1994. Every commercial grape rootstock nursery pays into it through mandatory assessments.
Duarte Nursery paid the assessments but challenged them in court twice. In the 1990s, it argued in federal court that the fee violated its rights to free speech and association. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals rejected that claim in 1998.
The nursery then sued in state court, arguing that the assessments violated its liberty interests and due process rights, and sought refunds. It said it had paid about $800,000 in assessments since 2000. The trial court ruled against it, and in August 2015 the Third District Court of Appeal affirmed. “In an appeal long on innuendo and short on evidence,” the court wrote, “plaintiff insinuates that a self-interested university researcher and some of plaintiff’s competitors used propaganda to dupe the Legislature.” The opinion also notes that the nursery admitted using a small amount of a rootstock developed through the commission’s research. The California Supreme Court declined to review the case.
Alexandra Duarte, a Republican, is running for California State Senate District 4 on the Nov. 3, 2026, ballot. She is married to former Rep. John Duarte, who has served as the nursery’s president.
Sources
- California Court of Appeal, Third District, Duarte Nursery, Inc. v. California Grape Rootstock Improvement Commission, No. C071578, Opinion (Aug. 25, 2015)(opens in new tab)
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Duarte Nursery, Inc. v. California Grape Rootstock Improvement Commission, 166 F.3d 342 (1998) (unpublished)
- California Supreme Court, Case No. S229744, docket (Nov. 24, 2015)
- University of California Statewide IPM Program, “Grape Phylloxera,” Pest Management Guidelines: Grape(opens in new tab)
- California Agriculture (University of California), “Phylloxera on rise: Deadly insect pest poses increased risk to north coast vineyards” (March 1991)(opens in new tab)
- California Department of Food and Agriculture, California Grape Rootstock Improvement Commission Law, Food and Agricultural Code § 74701 et seq.(opens in new tab)
Lawsuit allegations are claims, not findings, unless a court ruled. See something wrong? How to request a correction.
Read more: Alexandra Duarte for Senate: the full record


