
Duarte Nursery Knowingly Delivered Defective Trees to Farmers, a Court Ruling Says. The Nursery Kept Using Fine Print the Judge Called ‘Unconscionable.’
Farmers who planted Duarte Nursery trees say they lost orchards, harvests, and millions of dollars. In court, the nursery pointed to fine print capping what growers could recover. A judge found that growers who asked for refunds “were left with no remedy at all.”
- Since 2015, pistachio, avocado, and lemon growers have sued Duarte Nursery, saying trees they bought were defective or misrepresented.
- In 2022, a judge ruled the nursery’s fine print “unconscionable” and found that growers who asked for refunds “were left with no remedy at all.”
- Asked under oath why the nursery offered a lemon grower a refund, John Duarte said: “So, I wouldn’t sit in a room with lawyers when I could be out selling other trees.”














